Skip to main content

Judgementall Hai Kya - Why Are People So Judgmental?

A few years ago, a Hindi film was all set to release titled Mental Hai Kya? (Are You Mental?) As soon as the trailer of the film came out, there was an uproar. The film showcased a darkly comical approach to a murder with two primary suspects – an urban, charming young man and his mentally unstable neighbour, a young lady.

Casting aside the solid filmmaking and script, audiences and celebrities alike paid attention to the name of the film. Naming any part of the film ‘mental’ was absolutely not in keeping with today’s atmosphere and politically correct times.

The director and actors were called out, and heavy criticism was doled out. Was it constructive criticism? Perhaps. But it was lost in the hullabaloo of harsh, blameful words.

Eventually, the makers succumbed and changed the name of the film to Judgementall Hai Kya? (Are you Judgmental?) – a tongue-in-cheek retort to the criticism while retaining the original title. And yes, it was judgementall spelt wrongly with two Ls.

What fascinated me about the whole episode was how people jumped to conclusions about the film itself, lightning-quick. Defending the rights of people with mental disorders is one side of the situation. But why diss the film itself?

It was a question that fascinated me and I pondered over the various shades of human psychology.

I understood one crucial aspect of the human mind: when it carries conditioning, it fails to separate individual aspects of a situation. The title of the film was an issue, but that’s all the issue was. The film itself was wonderful.

But when we feel attacked, we attack back with full force, not caring where we hit or even who we hit.

What is constructive criticism? When we are able to come up with a productive solution to a genuine flaw in a product or person, we have practised constructive criticism.

When we put down the said product or person because we carry personal beliefs that don’t align with what they stand for, we are engaging in discounting them. In pop culture terms, we “cancel” them because they aren’t to our liking.

But who are we to judge? Why does judgment fill us with such an air of superiority and rightness?

A question for the ages, indeed, because it has existed since time immemorial.

If there’s anything to take away from the article, let it be this: criticism can be given with love. Criticism can be given with care and respect for the other person. Criticism can be given with empathy, while acknowledging the other person’s point of view.

It sounds like a lofty goal. But it is very much achievable.

What’s more, it transforms the life of the critic. Yes, the critic.

How?

Why not ponder over it? :)
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is Happiness – and Other Inanities

I know, I know. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of articles out there describing happiness and what it means, how to discover what makes us happy etc. etc. I’m not here to talk about any of that. Let’s play a game instead. Ready? And I want you to really play it, not just read it. Let’s begin. Think of someone you admire or love. This person could be a fictional character from a favourite book or TV show; they could be a celebrity, an entrepreneur perhaps. They must be someone though who is not accessible to you in daily life. You don’t have any chance of meeting them or speaking with them but you really wish that you could. Have you thought of someone? Okay, good! Now, take a few minutes and make two lists – five questions you want to ask this person and five things you want to tell them. And as you jot each down, imagine yourself asking or telling them these things; imagine also their reaction. How would they respond to your questions? What would they say to your sharing? I wan...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Self-Important Life

  “Modesty is the colour of virtue.” The essence of this saying by Diogenes, a Greek philosopher, has likely shaped our growing-up years. Indeed, to be modest and humble was the very definition of a talented person. The more intelligent one was the more modest one was expected to be. Like anything though, modesty is best had when served in moderate doses. Swing too far the other way and we’ll hit the first of the building blocks that make up our personality – self-esteem. Why is self-esteem important? Quoting Brene Brown, an American professor and author, “Authenticity is the daily practice of letting go of who we think we are supposed to be and embracing who we are.” High self-esteem naturally breaks down barriers and allows us to step into vulnerability. And what is vulnerability? Accepting ourselves as we are at any given moment. The more vulnerable we allow ourselves to be, the more authentic we become. And this root of being oneself stems from the value we give ourselves – in...
1 comment
Read more

Mantra Yoga

His first experience of awareness was his breath – he felt it descend into his lungs before moving slowly out of his nose into the pillow. He lay still, feeling his breath as he brought his attention to his body. It felt stiff; he’d been asleep in the same position all night long. He wiggled his toes gently and stretched out his fingers as breath continued to move in and out of his lungs. After a minute or so, he turned over onto his back. Keeping his torso in place, he stretched his arms and legs taut, releasing the stiffness and sending blood to every extremity. Bringing his knees to his chest, he rocked from side to side a few times. He then gently held his knees and rocked up and down three times before using the motion to sit up. Releasing his knees, he stood up and stretched one more time before heading to the washroom. He emerged twenty minutes later, freshly showered. Opening his cupboard, he pulled out a white kurta and loose white pants – his standard attire. Quietly pulling...
Post a Comment
Read more